What strikes me about this recording is that two different interpretations are going on at the same time. Maestro Sawallisch gives an intimate parlor reading of the cycle (much in keeping with Schubert's own milieu) while Thomas Hampson leads a full-blown operatic assault. This is disappointing because I prefer Hampson's work when he sings on a smaller scale. Just listen to his Scene from Faust in the Hyperion Schubert Edition, where he practically whispers into Marie McLauglin's ear. It is some of the most compelling drama I have ever heard.
I much prefer the recording of Winterreise by Thomas Allen and Roger Vignoles, where there is a strong sense that the performers are on the same page.
October 9, 2006I am both a great admirer of Schubert's songs and Thomas Hampson's singing. I waited for quite a few years to hear his rendition of this cycle, and, I must say, it was a disappointment. Hampson's tone and line are near-perfect, but he just doesn't seem to be involved with the text at all. It sounds like he is singing a grocery list or something. Sawallisch is outstanding, as you might expect.
I own several recordings of this cycle, have heard many more, and have even sung it myself. I would steer clear of this one, and look for Fischer-Dieskau, Hans Hotter, or Hermann Prey. There are many more that have real merrit. This is not one of them.
September 25, 2004I love this interpretation of Winterreise. Thomas Hampson's singing is so profound, so heartfelt here. He brings out the pain, the loss, he brings colour into the music. I don't claim to have heard hundreds of versions of this cycle, but I had heard more than one when I bought this CD, and for me it is the best of all. I highly recommend it!
July 8, 2004In most recordings, Hampson displays a beautiful voice governed by an intelligent mind and an open heart. Unfortunately, his Winter Journey feels more like a Spring Stroll; it lacks the emotional distress both poet & composer invested in this supreme song cycle. I respectfully suggest you pass on his Winterreise. Make the Journey instead with Hermann Prey, Fischer-Dieskau, or Jon Vickers (who sings many of the songs in baritone keys). This song cycle is one of the greatest works of art; don't compromise your experience with this particular Hampson recording.
June 7, 2004 |  | Great performance, crystal clear digital recording |  |
An hinthimistic travel through sentiment and emotion in hostile nature. A great Sawallisch performance, who intruduced to me Thomas Hampson in a perfect execution.
March 15, 2000More reviews at Amazon.com ...
(5 reviews)
