Though this is a work of fiction, it does in fact reveal the genius of Beethoven himself, through passions and rages of scorching intensity. Director Bernard Rose in the commentary compares the film's construction to that of "Citizen Kane," in that it begins with a mystery that begs to be solved if the man is to be understood. In this case, it's a final will bequeathing everything to his "Immortal Beloved," along with an undelivered billet-doux to the unknown woman. In the course of trying to fulfill the maestro's last wishes, the executor of Beethoven's estate explores the composer's past. Through flashbacks, Beethoven's dizzying genius and private pain are revealed. It's true, that there is some license here, but it's respectful of the facts, and tries to stay within the lines while exploring the possibilities. First, there really was such a final will discovered among his papers. Also, the custody battle over his nephew is well documented, and transcripts were consulted for some word-for-word re-creation, as Rose discloses in his commentary. The film takes license in that Rose purports to have solved the mystery, and he makes such a strong case, I'm partially convinced he has.
But all of that is merely a means of exploring Beethoven. A thorough knowledge of his music would probably heighten the appreciation of some references to it. For instance, thought I can't claim to know that much, I do know that the 5th Symphony is about fate knocking at one's door. The very first image of the film is of Beethoven's hoary head on a white pillow, surrounded by night. Lightning strobes in sync with the sudden obtrusion of the 5th. He succumbs. It was an artful touch, and there might be others similar to it that I didn't catch. But it adverted to me from the outset that this would be a meticulously crafted film.
For the performances by the actors, I'm not sure I'm being hyperbolic in saying that Gary Oldman is as stellar an actor as Beethoven was a composer. He was downright explosive at times, disdainful others, but somehow always sympathetic. His performance was nothing short of magnificent. In one of the two documentaries included on the disc, Oldman admits that he turned the role down a couple of times, until his agent convinced him it would be the right thing. Thank heaven! He was a fierce presence every time he was on the screen, as you'd imagine Beethoven himself must have been when he walked into a room.
If you already own the SD DVD, as I did, and you still love this film, I suggest you go ahead and upgrade to the Blu-ray. There is so much filigree in the location shots and the costumes, it definitely benefited throughout from the hi-def transfer, and made seeing it even more pleasurable. The artistry of the film is given a more rightful emphasis.
As for the special features, there's been nothing added from the previous SD edition. But in this case, the beauty of the film itself makes it worth the upgrade.
December 29, 2008 |  | Immortal Beloved, on Blu-ray is pure perfection! |  |
This is a magnificent film of great performances and inspired storytelling. I'm sure it plays fast and loose with historical fact, but anyone who can appreciate Beethoven's genius can surely find a fondness for this story. Gary Oldman portrays Beethoven with an aloof complexity; he leaves the viewer spellbound with a hunger for more about Beethoven's life. The supporting cast is equally impressive, with outstanding performances from Valeria Golino, Isabella Rossellini and Jeoren Krabbe. I can find no fault with Immortal Beloved as it tells an engrossing story through masterful performances and an amazing attention to period detail. Of course, the music of Beethoven is also profoundly moving, especially within the context of the film. This is a beautifully shot film with loads of natural grain and a fine attention to the most minute of period details.And speaking of detail, closely watch the many delicate fabrics that are used in the film's costuming. Beethoven's funeral is a notable scene where all of the women in attendance are wearing veils. The amount of detail in these veils is among the most startling fine film detail I've yet seen conveyed in a home video presentation. Immortal Beloved, on Blu-ray is pure perfection! TrueHD soundtrack is outstanding and succeeds in every aspect. Sure, there is one scene where cannon-fire is nicely directional, but the remainder of the film is more ambient with a focus on performed music taking up the appropriate space in your home theater. Most of this music relies on the front speakers, but rear fill adds a nice acoustic touch in reproducing the atmosphere from whatever room in which we are watching the music performed.
I've been a huge fan of the film for years and am thrilled to be able to experience it in my home in such outstanding quality.It would be a crime if I didn't give this film my highest recommendation.
December 27, 2008 | | Beautiful color, wonderful story. | |
The blu-ray transfer on "Immortal Beloved" is excellent. Everything is distinctly clear, and the colors are vivid. The acting is very good. Story is touching with a great ending. Keeps you guessing. Recommended.
December 24, 2008| | | Movie making at it's best. | |
If you have no appreciation for Beethoven or his music watching this film will undoubtedly change that. Directed with real verve and finely acted by the likes of Gary Oldman, I loved watching this film. I own this movie and drag it out every once in a while. Great recordings of his music by the current masters infuse some scenes with intense emotion: the emotions Beethoven himself must have felt. This is one of the finest period films I have seen, and can only recommend it highly.
November 25, 2008This movie has achieved the daunting task of being good enough for its music. I don't collect many movies because, even if I enjoyed them, I don't want to sit through them again after I know the endings. This is an exception. The acting and filmography are so great (not to mention the music) that I enjoy watching it over and over, even though I know the surprise ending. So well done.
November 2, 2008More reviews at Amazon.com ...
(180 reviews)