Suk: Summer Tale / Fantastic Scherzo - Charles Mackerras / Czech Philharmonic

Cross the openhearted geniality of Dvorák with the large scale and experimental fervor of Mahler and you have Josef Suk, a pupil of Dvorák whose life was changed forever when his wife (Dvorák's daughter) died young. The resulting anguish is where the Mahler element comes in. These works are not as filled with pain and grief as Suk's astonishing Asrael Symphony. In fact, the Scherzo is as happy as Dvorák's famous Scherzo capriccioso. But the broad range and sheer size of Summer Tale (about 50 minutes) are thoroughly Mahlerian, the music consistently involving and captivating. Mackerras, who studied under the great Czech conductor Vaclav Talich, is as completely attuned to Suk's idiom as the orchestra is, and the resulting performances, abetted by excellent sound, are real winners. Highly recommended, especially to lovers of late romanticism. --Leslie Gerber Amazon.com

Unusual late Romantic repertoire

The first thing to say about this lovely CD is that it showcases a world class orchestra in truly sumptuous sound. Mackerrras and the Czech Philharmonic could not be more subtle, expert and nuanced in their performance of this unusual, complex music; it's as close as you can get to a concert hall experience without actually being there. Suk's inventive orchestration and epic scale are both sensitively and thrillingly realised here by virtue of the wide range of dynamics in the recorded sound; particularly striking is the way the shimmering of the Czech strings - beautifully in tune - are caught, especially in the opening movement of the "Summer Tale". In addition to the influences of Dvorak and Czech folk in general, and the more obvious echoes of Strauss' tone poems and Mahler's Angst-laden symphonies, you will also hear similarities to the sound world of French Impressionist school; Suk often creates an atmosphere redolent of Ravel and Debussy. (I also hear some anticipation of Respighi's tone poems, too; the colour of the effects Suk generates with his large orchestra and use of snarling brass have something to do with it.)

There is always a lurking demon in Suk's music which almost undermines the sinuous melodies; this is not the unalloyed delight of Suk's charming "Serenade" - which was written as a result of Dvorak effectively advising his future son-in-law to "lighten up"! Dvorak's subsequent death, swiftly followed by that of his daughter, Suk's wife did nothing to help mitigate Suk's predilection for melancholy; the immediate result was the grand and gloomy "Asrael" symphony. The earlier "Fantastic Scherzo", written during Suk's happiest years, is more overtly and typically Czech in its rhythmic vitality and singing meolodies (especially the most prominent and frequently recurring one).

All in all, a superb record of fascinating music slightly off the beaten track in demonstration quality sound. May 30, 2008

Gorgeous moments

I have only heard the Summer Tale portion, which is where the 4-star rating comes in rather than a 5-star. I heard it for the first time ever last week. I was drawn in by the haunting beauty of the duet by what must be english horns. And continued to be in awe of the gorgeous moments interspersed in this piece. Parts are typical 20th century-sounding stuff that I normally don't like, but then Suk drops in these absolutely gorgeous and melodious themes that are riveting and compelling. A big YES to this piece! Try it, you'll like it! July 3, 2007

Some parts are questionable

Summer Tale Op.29 : "Voices of life and consolation" and Summer Tale Op.29 : "Noon" are difficult to hear. The music starts off very low in volume and then reaches a very loud pitch. I was disappointed in this section, but the rest of the CD was wonderful. September 12, 2005

Enticed by Fantastic Scherzo, Moved by A Summer Tale

Like many classical music lovers, I was more familiar with Joseph Suk's biography than I was with his music. His happy years as a husband with a famous father-in-law (Antonin Dvorak) and the loss he felt when his wife died is a somewhat well known tale, as is the darkness of his music after he was widowed. Yet with the exception of his march "Toward a New Life" and perhaps his "Serenade for Strings," which is often paired on recordings with his father in law's work of the same title, I did not know any of his music. Then our local classical station, WCRB began playing "Fantastic Scherzo" with some regularity. I mistakenly thought it was a piece by Dvorak until I heard the announcer state the work's title. I decided this work is a must have, and so I purchased the recording.

My primary interest in the recording is "Fantastic Scherzo." Sir Charles Mackerras brings out the entire flavor this sumptuous and dreamy piece has to offer. It surprises me that the work is not a more popular concert piece and is not available on more recordings, yet I cannot imagine that the work would be significantly better handled by any other conductor.

Since I purchased the disc primarily for "Fantastic Scherzo," I was not all that interested in "A Summer Tale," at least at first. One day while driving, I decided to give it a listening to, and was amazed at its beauty and complexity. While "Fantastic Scherzo" is a lighter work, reminiscent of his famous father-in-law, "A Summer Tale" reflects other early twentieth century musical influences, particularly Mahler. Listeners will see a variety in the styles of the various movements. As one can except from a conductor such as Mackerras, he explores the work's nuances and subtleties well and is in complete control of the orchestra.

Recordings such as this show that Suk deserves more attention than he often receives. Since most record labels are somewhat skittish (a mild understatement) about releasing new recordings, we may not find all that many new recordings of Suk's work in the near future, but at least we have this recording to give us a glimpse of what we are missing.
September 1, 2004

Massive and Mahlerian

Josef Suk should be far better known, especially when promoted by terrific recordings like this one. Anyone who admires the vast landscapes of Strauss or Mahler should respond to Suk's equally compelling terrain.

The main draw here is "A Summer's Tale," a gigantic tone poem that perfectly harnesses the resources of a huge orchestra -- in this case, the glorious Czech Philharmonic. Sir Charles Mackerras, long an advocate of composers like Janacek and Martinu, here shows that Suk should also be as well-known as either of these.

The filler, the "Fantastic Scherzo," is performed with equal commitment and fervor. (To my ears, the piece needs a new title; it's a little more laid-back and congenial than the word "scherzo" normally indicates.)

Decca's recording is clear, warm and detailed, and only adds to the impact. This is an exceptional recording of seldom-played repertoire, and can't be recommended highly enough. (NB: For those interested in hearing another outstanding version of "A Summer's Tale," a Virgin recording with Libor Pesek and the Royal Liverpool Philharmonic Orchestra is also quite marvelous.) July 29, 2003

More reviews at Amazon.com ...