Wilco - Yankee Hotel Foxtrot

heartbreakingly gorgeous

I'd given this album a listen a few years ago, and while appreciative of it, it didn't stick, and so I returned it to the shelf from whence it came. I've been a fan of Uncle Tupelo and listened to both Son Volt and Wilco's earlier efforts, but I just didn't get the attraction.

I recently popped it back into my CD player (yes, those things still exist) and now I can't get enough of it. "Radio Cure" may be one of the most beautiful songs ever written, and "Poor Places" with its driving minor counterpoint is another one of my favorites. The album is not one with only a few good tracks and is best enjoyed to as a whole.

My only fear is that I love it so much, I may over-listen and grow tired of hearing it. Let's hope that doesn't happen. November 29, 2008

Only for those who believe they are music snobs

I have always like this band......Jeff Tweedy's band following the break-up of Uncle Tupelo. However, it amazes me that anyone who listens to this CD can give it 5 stars. It is an amalgamation of incoherent, irritating and unlistenable noise.
Those who grade this with more than one star are either band members, close friends of the band or those who think of themselves as music afficionado's who know more about music than you do (similar to liberal Democrats who believe they know how to spend your money better than yourself). They can say to there snobby afficionado friends that they "get" this CD. Other, "less intelligent listeners", do not understand the depth of this music. What a load of bull.....I own thousands of CD's of all genres, and regardless of what music categroy you would like to place this CD into.....it qualifies as garbage in every one.
Avoid this CD/Album at all costs.....Unlistenable....... October 16, 2008

I've got reservations

I heard about this album a few years ago from a friend who's even farther into the frontiers of modern pop than I am. It took a little patience, but I got to like it quite a bit. The songwriting is solid with a nice country tinge, and the performance is excellent: I particularly like the piano parts, not to mention the distinctive rasp of Jeff Tweedy's voice. The album deserves classic status on the sound of the vocals alone.

But as many nice things as I have to say about it, there are flaws in YHF that bother me more the more I listen to it. It's very noisy - which would be okay, except that a lot of the noise doesn't fit. Listen to OK Computer (another noisy record) and you'll be hard-pressed to find a single sound that doesn't blend perfectly into the soundscape; on YHF, though, I sometimes have to strain to hear the actual song over a burst of static or feedback. The stretches of noise are too long and too harsh: they end up working against the music rather than with it.

Overall I really admire Wilco's work, and not just on this album. But it seems to me that some parts of YHF were a lot more fun to make than to listen to. October 3, 2008

Imagine Cloning Blonde On Blonde With Sgt Pepper

What if Bob Dylan joined the Beatles? That is Wilco! Jeff Tweedy is the driving force behind this group. Is Yankee Hotel Foxtrot that good? Can it rank up there with Blonde On Blonde and Sgt Pepper? You decide. September 25, 2008

Not Quite As Described, But A Sweet Album

So maybe I was kind of disappointed that Yankee Hotel Foxtrot doesn't have as much country influence. This band is grouped as Alt Country, and I always thought the genre label sounded good. Well, so much for that (hey I hate classifying genres and lumping bands into a single genre, but most people who listen to it actually believe they sort of fit into the category. From what I have heard (as of sound samples and such), their double album Being There, sounds a lot more country but retains the Wilco sound I seem to be attracted to on this album.

Yankee Hotel Foxtrot is a freaking great album. Even though there was a lack of country sometimes, it's there, and it's more than just that. Electronic, folk, well, you can't lump just one genre on it. Wilco's lyrics, by Jeff Tweedy are melancholy, yet hopeful. His voice is a bit rough at times, but I am perfectly fine with that, because his voice still is emotional and sounds great.

The music is one of the stars of this album. If you ask me, the music, while not background, will establish a mood, in ways that is pretty excellent, actually. Jesus Etc, with it's strings, fits an image of a stranded man trapped in the office of the World Trade Center, lamenting to his wife on the phone. Kamera feels light and breezy, and the song even matches when I walk. Radio Cure's somber mood makes everything a whole lot better. People who like varied music that you can't pigenhole into one genre will love the music, and the pop sensibility helps the album a _______load.

There isn't a bad song on this record. Yes, some songs are better than others, but that's going to happen. But that's not really saying much, since none of these songs are merely average. Heavy Metal Drummer is kind of a lone duck, but it's the first Wilco song I heard. This one catchy scattered with with electronic music. I am Trying To Break Your Heart, the first hit, is loaded with melancholy lush instrumentation. War On War is loaded with so much mood and irrestibility it's pretty hard not to love it. Highlights pretty much abound on this album.

So what's exactly wrong with the score? Well, I still don't exactly think this is Grade A material, but dang, that still won't change the fact that it still owns. SOme of the experimentation isn't as interseting. The guitar line that opens up the otherwise excellent I'm The Man Who Loves You, for example. Yes, Tweedy has a couple of blah signing parts, but that's a minor quirk.

Believe the hype. Don't worry about shallow alt country losers like Ryan Adams, Wilco owns. Also check out Son Volt and Uncle Tupelo while your at it.

9.0/10 September 15, 2008

More reviews at Amazon.com ...